SCPME Forum

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

The Simon Center for the Professional Military Ethic


    A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul

    Poll

    Ethical or Unethical?

    [ 0 ]
    A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Bar_left0%A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Bar_right [0%] 
    [ 0 ]
    A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Bar_left0%A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Bar_right [0%] 
    [ 0 ]
    A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Bar_left0%A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Bar_right [0%] 

    Total Votes: 0
    Admin
    Admin
    Admin


    Posts : 99
    Join date : 2009-10-26
    Location : West Point, NY

    A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul Empty A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul

    Post by Admin Thu Oct 29, 2009 11:25 am

    A Sports Illustrated Reporter Plays Foul

    The Huffington Post
    by Richard Bradley

    Oct 17th 2005

    Michelle Wie has been disqualified from her first professional tournament after a reporter for Sports Illustrated told tournament officials that he thought she had violated tour rules when she dropped a ball too far from its original landing spot.

    No one has suggested that Wie intentionally did anything improper—which means that the real story here is whether the reporter's actions were appropriate. Was it ethical for a reporter to involve himself in a golf tournament in such a manner? The answer is no.

    According to the AP story linked to above, "Michael Bamberger, a reporter for Sports Illustrated, told tour officials Sunday afternoon that he was concerned about the drop."

    "Asked why he didn't bring it up before the third round ended"—when Wie could have avoided disqualification— "Bamberger said, 'That didn't occur to me. I was still in my reporter's mode. I wanted to talk to her first.'"

    As time passed, Bamberger added, "I thought about it more and was just uncomfortable that I knew something. Integrity is at the heart of the game. I don't think she cheated. I think she was just hasty."

    Let's review. By his own admission, Bamberger stepped out of reporter mode when raising the issue with tour officials. He thinks integrity is at the heart of golf, but he doesn't think Wie cheated—so what integrity is at stake? Then, when it's too late to rectify the error, Bamberger causes Wie to be disqualified from her first pro tournament. He doesn't do it because he's reporting a story, but because he's "uncomfortable that [he] knew something."

    What an unfortunate incident; Bamberger shouldn't sleep well about this one. He should publicly apologize to Wie, and Sports Illustrated should pay her the $50,000 that she lost because of Bamberger, who—not Wie—is really the one who crossed the line.

    Did he cross the line and was it unethical of him?

      Current date/time is Fri Mar 29, 2024 2:33 am